Back to Blog

Dilapidations: A Complete Guide for Commercial Tenants and Landlords

January 2025 13 min read
Commercial property dilapidations inspection
£50k+
Average Claim Value
60-70%
Typical Settlement Rate
56 Days
Response Timeframe
Section 18(1)
Protection Cap

Dilapidations represent one of the most significant financial risks for commercial tenants leasing property across Milton Keynes, Bedford, Northampton, and the wider region. At Milton Keynes Surveyors, our chartered building surveyors regularly advise both commercial tenants and landlords on dilapidations matters, helping minimize liability, resolve disputes, and ensure fair settlements.

This comprehensive guide explains everything you need to know about commercial dilapidations, from understanding your lease obligations to negotiating terminal schedules and protecting your financial interests.

Critical for Commercial Tenants: Dilapidations claims frequently exceed £50,000-£100,000+. Understanding your obligations and taking proactive measures can save tens of thousands of pounds.

What Are Dilapidations?

Dilapidations are breaches of lease covenantsLegal obligations in your commercial lease regarding property condition and maintenance relating to the physical condition of commercial property. When a commercial lease ends, landlords assess whether the tenant has fulfilled their repairing obligations and returned the property in the required condition. Any breaches constitute dilapidations for which the landlord can seek financial compensation.

What Dilapidations Claims Commonly Include

  • Failure to maintain and repair - Property deterioration during tenancy
  • Damage beyond fair wear and tear - Excessive deterioration from use
  • Alterations not reinstated - Fit-outs, partitions, fixtures not removed
  • Decoration not maintained - Failure to redecorate per lease requirements
  • Outstanding statutory compliance - Fire safety, asbestos, H&S issues
  • Failure to yield up in covenanted condition - Property not returned as required

Types of Dilapidations

Terminal Dilapidations (Most Common)

Terminal dilapidations arise at lease end when the tenant vacates. This is the most common and financially significant type of dilapidations claim affecting commercial tenants throughout Milton Keynes and the surrounding area.

The Process:

  1. Tenant vacates property at lease end
  2. Landlord's surveyor inspects the vacated property
  3. Schedule of dilapidations prepared listing all breaches
  4. Landlord serves schedule with cost estimates
  5. Landlord seeks financial compensation for breaches
Typical Terminal Claims: Range from £10,000-£200,000+ depending on property size, condition, and lease terms. Office properties in Milton Keynes typically see £30,000-£80,000 claims.

Interim Dilapidations (During Tenancy)

Interim dilapidations claims can arise during the lease term if the landlord believes the tenant is failing to maintain the property in accordance with lease obligations.

When Used:

  • Landlord notices significant property deterioration
  • Tenant neglecting routine maintenance
  • Warning mechanism before terminal claims
  • Protecting landlord's asset value

Tenant Rights: Can challenge interim schedules, have time to complete works, may dispute whether breaches are genuine

Yield-Up Obligations

The yield-up clause in commercial leases specifies the exact condition in which property must be returned at lease end.

Typical Yield-Up Requirements:

  • Full decoration throughout
  • All repairs completed
  • Alterations reinstated (unless agreed otherwise)
  • Statutory compliance achieved
  • Property cleaned and cleared
  • All tenant fixtures removed
Read Your Lease: Yield-up clauses vary significantly. Understanding your specific obligations 12-18 months before lease end allows proper planning and budgeting.

Dilapidations Cost Estimator

Estimate Your Potential Dilapidations Liability

This tool provides a rough estimate of potential dilapidations costs based on property characteristics and condition:

Dilapidations schedule documentation

Understanding Lease Repairing Obligations

Your liability for dilapidations depends entirely on your lease terms. Milton Keynes Surveyors strongly recommends all commercial tenants understand their repairing obligations before signing leases.

Lease Types Comparison

Lease Type Tenant Responsibility Dilapidations Risk Typical Use
FRI (Full Repairing & Insuring) Everything - structure, exterior, interior, services Highest - full exposure Most commercial leases in Milton Keynes
Internal Repairing Only Internal areas, fixtures, fittings only Moderate - limited to internals Multi-let buildings, retail units
With Schedule of Condition Limited to not worsening documented condition Lower - capped liability Older properties, negotiated leases
Landlord Maintains Minimal - tenant use only Very low - rare exposure Rare in modern commercial leases

FRI Leases: Maximum Exposure

Most commercial leases in Milton Keynes, Bedford, and Northampton are FRI leases placing full repairing responsibility on the tenant, regardless of property condition at lease start.

Under FRI leases, tenants must:

  • Maintain and repair the entire property throughout the tenancy
  • Return property in good repair at lease end
  • Carry out repairs regardless of whether defects existed when they took occupation
  • Pay buildings insurance premiums
  • Comply with all statutory requirements
Critical Warning: FRI leases create MAXIMUM exposure to dilapidations claims. Tenants of older properties can face £100,000+ claims for deterioration that occurred before they even occupied the property. ALWAYS negotiate a schedule of condition for older/deteriorated properties.

Schedules of Condition: Your Protection

A schedule of condition prepared at lease commencement documents the property's existing state with photographs and detailed descriptions. This limits the tenant's repairing obligation - they must return property no worse than the condition recorded in the schedule.

Essential Protection: Schedules of condition are CRUCIAL for tenants of older properties. They can save £50,000-£100,000+ in dilapidations claims by proving deterioration existed before occupation.

What Should Be Included:

  • Comprehensive photographs of all areas
  • Detailed written descriptions of condition
  • Documentation of all existing defects
  • Notes on decoration state
  • Services condition
  • External areas and structures

Cost: £1,000-£3,000 typically - a bargain compared to potential savings

The Dilapidations Process Timeline

1

12-18 Months Before Lease End

Tenant Action: Commission pre-expiry inspection by chartered surveyor. Identify potential breaches early, get repair quotes, decide whether to complete works voluntarily or settle financially.

2

6 Months Before Lease End

Tenant Action: Begin addressing obvious issues if cost-effective. Negotiate with landlord about retention of alterations. Consider whether to complete voluntary works or accept dilapidations claim.

3

Lease End - Vacation

Tenant vacates property. Property should be cleared, cleaned, and ideally with obvious repairs completed if economical.

4

Within 2-4 Weeks Post-Vacation

Landlord Action: Commission surveyor to inspect vacated property and prepare terminal schedule of dilapidations.

5

Schedule Served (within 2-3 months)

Landlord serves terminal schedule listing all alleged breaches, required works, and cost estimates. Claims typically range £20,000-£150,000+.

6

56 Days to Respond

Tenant MUST respond within 56 days per Dilapidations Protocol. Instruct chartered surveyor immediately to prepare comprehensive response (Scott Schedule).

7

Negotiation Period (2-6 months)

Surveyors negotiate settlement. Most claims settle at 60-70% of original demand through professional negotiation. Section 18(1), supersession, and betterment arguments reduce claims significantly.

8

Settlement or Litigation

Final outcome: 90%+ settle through negotiation. Litigation is expensive and time-consuming for both parties. Mediation often used if negotiation stalls.

Landlord's Claim Limitations

Important legal principles limit landlords' dilapidations claims, protecting tenants from excessive demands:

Section 18(1) Landlord & Tenant Act 1927 (CRITICAL PROTECTION)

This crucial legislation caps landlords' dilapidations claims at the diminution in property value caused by disrepair.

Example: Landlord claims £100,000 for repairs. But property's value is only reduced by £30,000 due to disrepair. Claim is capped at £30,000 under Section 18(1). This saves tenant £70,000!

Section 18(1) is particularly significant when:

  • Landlord intends to demolish - No diminution if building is being demolished
  • Substantial redevelopment planned - Repair costs irrelevant if property being redeveloped
  • Property would be refurbished anyway - No diminution if landlord was planning works
  • Market conditions - If repairs don't affect rental value or sale price
  • Property being sold - Sale price demonstrates actual diminution
Tenant Strategy: ALWAYS investigate landlord's intentions for the property. If they're planning any works, Section 18(1) arguments can dramatically reduce claims. Your surveyor should obtain evidence of landlord's plans.

Supersession

Supersession applies when landlords' intended works would supersede repairs claimed in dilapidations schedules.

Example: Landlord claims £15,000 for redecoration and ceiling repairs. But landlord intends to strip out and reconfigure the office space anyway. These claimed repairs would be superseded by the landlord's works, so cannot be recovered.

When Supersession Applies:

  • Landlord planning full refurbishment
  • Demolition or substantial alteration intended
  • Change of use requiring complete refit
  • Works would necessarily involve removing/replacing claimed items

Betterment

Landlords cannot profit from dilapidations claims through betterment - receiving property in better condition than lease covenants required.

Examples:

  • If lease requires "good repair," landlord can't claim for works that would put property in "excellent repair"
  • If replacing like-for-like is adequate, landlord can't claim for upgrades to superior materials
  • Modern equivalent specifications may cost less than exact replacements

Common Dilapidations Issues

Decoration Requirements

Most commercial leases require decoration every 3-5 years and at lease end. Failure to redecorate is one of the most common dilapidations claims.

Typical Claims: £5-£15 per sq ft for full redecoration

  • 5,000 sq ft office = £25,000-£75,000 decoration claim
  • Includes preparation, materials, labor
  • Professional fees added (10-15%)
Defense Strategy: Challenge gold-plated specifications. Decoration only needs to meet lease standard, not exceed it. If lease says "two coats emulsion," landlord can't claim for three coats plus sealer.

Reinstatement of Alterations

Tenants who made alterations (with or without consent) are usually required to reinstate at lease end. This can be extremely costly, particularly for substantial fit-outs.

Major Cost Risk: Reinstatement of substantial fit-outs can cost £50,000-£200,000+. ALWAYS negotiate retention of alterations with landlords before vacation.

Negotiation Strategy:

  • Approach landlord 6-12 months before lease end
  • Highlight that alterations may benefit next tenant
  • Offer to leave alterations in exchange for reduced/waived dilapidations
  • Many landlords prefer to keep useful alterations

Fair Wear and Tear

Tenants are not liable for fair wear and tear - reasonable deterioration through normal use. However, defining "fair wear and tear" often causes disputes.

Generally Accepted as Fair Wear and Tear:

  • Gradual fading of decoration from sunlight
  • Minor carpet wear in high-traffic areas
  • General aging of materials within expected lifespan

NOT Fair Wear and Tear:

  • Damage from misuse or accidents
  • Failure to carry out regular maintenance
  • Deterioration that could have been prevented by proper maintenance
  • Neglect of lease obligations

Statutory Compliance

Leases typically require compliance with statutory requirements (fire safety, asbestos, health and safety, accessibility, etc.). Non-compliance can result in substantial dilapidations claims for remedial works.

Common Compliance Issues:

  • Fire risk assessments not up to date - £2,000-£10,000 to remedy
  • Asbestos surveys/management not current - £1,000-£5,000
  • Emergency lighting not certified - £500-£3,000
  • Fire alarm systems not maintained - £2,000-£8,000
  • Disability access not compliant - £5,000-£50,000+
Commercial property condition comparison

Strategies for Minimizing Dilapidations Liability

Protect Yourself Before Signing

Active Management During Lease Term

Pre-Vacation Preparation

Responding to Dilapidations Claims

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I do repairs myself to avoid dilapidations?

Yes, carrying out repairs before vacation can reduce liability, and is often cheaper than settling claims. However, ensure works meet lease covenant standards - poor quality repairs may not discharge obligations and landlord can still claim.

Best practice: Get professional contractors, obtain proper invoices, take photos of completed works. This provides evidence you've complied with obligations.

How long do landlords have to pursue dilapidations claims?

Six years from lease end for most claims under contract law. However, landlords should serve schedules reasonably promptly (typically within 2-6 months of vacation). Unreasonable delays may affect recoverability.

What if I can't afford the dilapidations claim?

Engage experienced RICS surveyors to challenge excessive claims and negotiate reasonable settlements. Most claims settle at significantly reduced levels (60-70% of original demand) through professional negotiation.

Payment plans can sometimes be negotiated. In extreme cases, consider company voluntary arrangement or administration, but seek professional advice first.

Do I need to return property exactly as I found it?

Not exactly - you must return it in accordance with lease covenants, subject to fair wear and tear. If you have a schedule of condition, you only need to return property no worse than the documented initial condition.

Without a schedule of condition, FRI leases may require you to return property in "good repair" regardless of its condition when you took occupation - hence schedules are so valuable.

What's a reasonable settlement percentage?

Most dilapidations disputes settle at 60-70% of the landlord's original claim through professional negotiation. Factors affecting settlement:

  • Strength of Section 18(1) arguments
  • Evidence of landlord's intentions (supersession)
  • Quality of schedule of condition (if exists)
  • Fair wear and tear arguments
  • Whether items are genuine lease breaches
  • Reasonableness of landlord's costings

Well-prepared responses by experienced surveyors frequently achieve 50% or better reductions.

Conclusion: Protect Your Business from Dilapidations Exposure

Commercial dilapidations represent significant financial exposure for tenants and important asset management considerations for landlords across Milton Keynes, Bedford, Northampton, and the wider region. Understanding your lease obligations, taking proactive measures during tenancies, and instructing experienced RICS chartered surveyors are essential for protecting your interests and minimizing liability.

60-70%
Typical Settlement Rate
£20k-£50k
Average Savings Through Negotiation
90%+
Settle Without Litigation

Milton Keynes Surveyors provide comprehensive dilapidations services for both commercial tenants and landlords, including:

  • Pre-expiry inspections (12-18 months before lease end)
  • Terminal schedule preparation for landlords
  • Scott Schedule responses for tenants
  • Negotiation and dispute resolution
  • Expert witness services if litigation required
  • Schedules of condition at lease commencement

Our chartered building surveyors have extensive experience resolving dilapidations disputes throughout the region, saving clients tens of thousands of pounds through professional negotiation and robust technical responses.

Need Dilapidations Advice?

Whether you're a tenant facing a dilapidations claim or a landlord seeking to recover costs for property disrepair, our chartered surveyors provide expert professional advice tailored to your specific circumstances.

We help with:

  • Pre-expiry inspections to identify issues early
  • Responding to terminal schedules of dilapidations
  • Negotiating reasonable settlements
  • Preparing terminal schedules for landlords
  • Schedules of condition to protect tenant interests
Get Expert Dilapidations Advice

Request Your Survey Quote

Get expert RICS surveying advice from Milton Keynes Surveyors